A GitHub API token leaked from Homebrew’s Jenkins provided a security researcher with access to core Homebrew software repositories (repos).
Around since 2009, Homebrew is a free and open-source software package management system that is integrated with command line and which allows for simple installation of software on macOS machines.
On July 31, 2018, security researcher Eric Holmes discovered that an exposed token provided him with commit access to Homebrew/brew, Homebrew/homebrew-core, and Homebrew/formulae.brew.sh repositories.
With hundreds of thousands of people using Homebrew, the potential impact of the compromise was disastrous. By modifying a highly popular package, such as openssl, the researcher could have pushed the malicious code directly to a large number of users.
“If I were a malicious actor, I could have made a small, likely unnoticed change to the openssl formulae, placing a backdoor on any machine that installed it,” Holmes explained.
The issue, which was addressed the same day that it was discovered, did not result in compromised packages, Homebrew lead maintainer Mike McQuaid reveals.
The exposed token had elevated scopes, but the GitHub Support team has verified that it hasn’t been used to perform any pushes to Homebrew/brew or Homebrew/homebrew-core.
“Within a few hours the credentials had been revoked, replaced and sanitised within Jenkins so they would not be revealed in future. Homebrew/brew and Homebrew/homebrew-core were updated so non-administrators on those repositories cannot push directly to master,” McQuaid says.
He also explains that the team also enforced stronger security by updating most repositories in the Homebrew organization “to require CI checks from a pull request to pass before changes can be pushed to master.”
In addition to enabling branch protection and requiring reviews on additional repositories, the Homebrew team also required all maintainers to review and prune their personal access tokens and disable SMS fallback for 2FA.
“We try our best to behave as a for-profit company would do in terms of timely response to security issues but this is heavily limited by our lack of resources. For example, in this the Homebrew maintainer who resolved the above issues was on paternity leave from work and the primary carer for their child and had to reach a quick resolution while their child had a nap,” McQuaid notes.
In the wake of recent incidents with compromised Gentoo Linux and Arch Linux AUR repositories, it is increasingly clear that malicious actors can cause a great deal of damage by targeting the supply chain. This is exactly what last year’s CCleaner and NotPetya attacks demonstrated as well.
“This is my growing concern, and it’s been proven time and time again that package managers, and credential leaks, are a weak point in the security of the internet, and that supply chain attacks are a real and persistent threat. This is not a weakness in Homebrew, but rather a systemic problem in the industry, and one where we need more security research,” Holmes concludes.
